Date: Fri, 29 Nov 2002 09:08:25 -0500 From: "Kenneth S." <nimrodnopsams.com> Subject: Re: Thinking of buying a 1999 SAAB 95
Eric wrote: > > "Kenneth S." <nimrodnopsams.com> wrote in message news:<3DE63BF8.3EC0nopsams.com>... > > Once was Bob wrote: > > > > > > On 27 Nov 2002 13:52:05 -0800, Eric_1234nopsamast.net (Eric) wrote: > > > > > > >Greetings; I am a new member of GOOGLE groups but a long time reader > > > >of your wisdom regarding SAABs. I currently have a 1996 900SE that is > > > >giving me lots of "check engine" problems and am thinking of trading > > > > > > Not to change the subject... but I assume you've changed the gas cap ? > > > > > > Bob > > > > > > I had check engine problems in my 1996 900SE in the early part of last > > year, and endured repeated and tiresome visits to the dealer to try to > > get them fixed. Finally, the dealer resoldered some wiring, and that > > took care of the problem for just over a year. Then, a few weeks ago, > > it came back. > > > > Just as before, the check engine light came on for no apparent reason, > > as I was stopped in traffic. It stayed on, but there was no difference > > in the driveability of the car. This time I took it to an independent > > Saab specialist. They said they were getting a trouble code indicating > > a vaccuum leak, but there was no sign of a vaccuum leak in the engine. > > They recommended getting a new gas cap, although I said that I had had > > the gas cap tested at the time of the last round of problems, and there > > was nothing wrong with it. So I got a new gas cap, and in the > > intervening two weeks the check engine light hasn't come on again. (Of > > course, part of the reason may be that I don't drive the Saab much, and > > normally drive my endlessly reliable and fun-to-drive Mazda MX-5 Miata.) > > Actually, yes, I have changed out the gas cap due to a "learning > experience" a few years ago when I forgot it and the lamp came on. > Took it to the dealer and recieved a lesson on the check engine lamp. > Without getting in to the problem too much, I have replaced the O2 > sensors seven or eight times, the ECU twice, the seals around the gas > cap vent (?) and the catalytic converter. Total trips to the shop for > this problem over the last two years is near a dozen. I often wonder > if it is something that the state puts in the gas as an additive to > cut down on polution since I have used Exxon, Shell, BP, Chevron, > COSTCO, etc and none seems to prevent this from recurring. Anyways > thanks for the idea. > > Eric It's not a popular point of view in this news group, but I think this is most likely a Saab design flaw. I've never had these problems with any car other than my Saab. Always, with other cars, the check engine light was an indication that the oxygen sensor needed to be changed. When I took my car in a few weeks ago, I provided the independent Saab specialist with records showing what had been done last year at the dealers to take care of the problem. This included replacement of the oxygen sensor on a trial basis, and then taking it out again when the check engine light returned anyway. The independent mechanic told me that an oxygen sensor for my car would cost about $400, which I find astounding. My understanding is that they cost well under $100 for other cars.